[Physics FAQ] - [Copyright]
Written by PEG and SIC, but updated occasionally.
An Introduction to the Physics Newsgroups
The physics groups
The USENET hierarchy contains a number of newsgroups dedicated to the
discussion of physics and physics-related topics. These include
sci.physics, sci.physics.research, sci.physics.cond-matter, sci.physics.particle
and alt.sci.physics.new-theories, to all of which this general physics FAQ is
relevant. Some of the more narrowly focused physics newsgroups have their
own FAQs, which can, of course, be found in the appropriate newsgroups.
sci.physics is an unmoderated newsgroup
dedicated to the discussion of physics, news from the physics community, and
physics-related social issues.
sci.physics.research is a
moderated newsgroup designed to offer an environment with less traffic
and more opportunity for discussion of serious topics in physics among experts
and beginners alike. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group and also a regular
administrivia posting.
alt.sci.physics.new-theories
is an open forum for discussion of any topics related to conventional or
unconventional physics. In this context, "unconventional physics" includes
any ideas on physical science, whether or not they are widely accepted by the
mainstream physics community.
sci.physics.particle is an
unmoderated newsgroup dedicated to the discussion of all aspects of particle
physics by people with all levels of expertise. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group.
sci.physics.accelerators
is an unmoderated newsgroup for issues relating to particle accelerators and the
physics of beams. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group.
alt.sci.physics.acoustics
is an unmoderated newsgroup for issues relating to sound and acoustics. It
has an FAQ and
operates under a set of informal
rules.
sci.physics.cond-matter is
an unmoderated newsgroup dedicated to the discussion of the physics of condensed
matter. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group.
sci.physics.computational.fluid-dynamics
is an unmoderated newsgroup for discussion of computational fluid
dynamics. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group.
sci.physics.electromag is an
unmoderated newsgroup with its own FAQ dedicated to the discussion of topics
pertaining to electromagnetics. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group, and an early FAQ.
sci.physics.fusion is an
unmoderated newsgroup with its own FAQ dedicated to the discussion of nuclear
fusion. There is a
reconstructed charter for this group.
sci.physics.plasma is a
moderated newsgroup serving the plasma science and technologies
community. There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group.
sci.physics.relativity is an
unmoderated newsgroup for discussions about the theory of relativity.
There is an archive
copy of the charter for this group.
alt.sci.physics I don't know
why it exists, but it does.
de.sci.physik is the German language
group for physics discussions.
fj.sci.physics is the Japanese
language group for physics discussions.
Posting guidelines
People from a wide variety of non-physics backgrounds, as well as students
and experts in all areas of physics participate in the ongoing discussions on
these newsgroups. Professors, industrial scientists, graduate students,
etc., are all on hand to bring physics expertise to bear on almost any
question. But the only requirement for participation is interest in
physics, so feel free to post--but before you do, please do the following:
- Read this FAQ. It contains good answers, contributed by the
readership, to some of the most frequently asked questions.
- Understand "netiquette." If you are not sure what this means, subscribe to
news.announce.newusers and read the excellent discussion of proper net
behaviour that is posted there periodically.
- Be aware that there is a special newsgroup dedicated to the discussion of
"alternative" physics. It is alt.sci.physics.new-theories, and is the
appropriate forum for discussion of physics ideas that are not widely accepted
by the physics community. sci.physics is not the group for such
discussions. A quick look at articles posted to both groups should make
the distinction apparent. The charter for sci.physics.relativity also
allows for speculative subjects.
- Be conservative with crossposting. It is almost always best to post
a question in the one group that seems best suited rather than cross-posting
it to several groups. Check which newsgroups a thread is cross-posted to
before posting follow-ups. If it is inappropriately cross-posted you may
wish to reduce the number of groups listed in the header. Be aware that
if it is cross-posted to sci.physics.research or another moderated newsgroup,
your follow-ups will be vetted by the moderators before being accepted.
Posting the same message to many groups without cross-posting is even worse
than massive cross-posting.
- Read the responses already posted in the thread to which you want to
contribute. If a good answer is already posted, or the point you wanted
to make has already been made, let it be. Old questions have probably
been thoroughly discussed by the time you get there--save bandwidth by posting
only new information. Post to as narrow a geographic region as is
appropriate. If your comments are directed at only one person, try
email.
- Get the facts right! Opinions may differ, but facts should
not. It is very tempting for new participants to jump in with quick
answers to physics questions posed to the group. But it is very easy to
end up feeling silly when people barrage you with corrections. So before
you give us all a physics lesson you'll regret--look it up.
- Don't post textbook problems in the hope that someone will do your
homework for you. Do your own homework; it's good for you. On the
other hand, questions, even about elementary physics, are always
welcome. So if you want to discuss the physics that is relevant to your
homework, feel free to do so. Be warned that you may still have plenty
of work to do, trying to figure out which of the many answers you get are
correct.
- Your postings will be read by thousands of people so it is worth taking a
minute to read it back and check the spelling, grammar and punctuation before
posting, but please don't waste bandwidth by correcting or criticising other
peoples spelling or grammar unless their errors obscure what was being
said. Pointless spelling corrections almost always draw responses that
correct spelling errors in the correction!
- Do not post picture binaries or other large files in the sci.physics.*
hierarchy of newsgroups. If you want to show a picture post it in alt.binaries.pictures.misc and tell
everyone where to find it. Better still, put it on a web page and post
the URL.
- Be prepared for heated discussion. People have strong opinions about
the issues, and discussions can get a little "loud" at times. Don't take
it personally if someone seems to always jump all over everything you
say. Everyone was jumping all over everybody long before you got
there! You can keep the discussion at a low boil by trying to stick to
the facts. Clearly separate facts from opinion--don't let people think
you are confusing your opinions with scientific truth. And keep the
focus of discussion on the ideas, not the people who post them.
- Tolerate everyone. People of many different points of view, and
widely varying educational backgrounds from around the world participate in
this newsgroup. Respect for others will be returned in kind.
Personal criticism is usually not welcome.
Thank you for taking the time to read this page.